Exercise 10B: Who burned it, who bears it
Pages: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/pledges/, "Pledges and Paths"; three tables from Our World in Data (ourworldindata.org); and the ND-GAIN Country Index of the Notre Dame Global Adaptation Initiative (gain.nd.edu)
Chapter: 10, "Climate Justice and Ethics" (with Chapter 15, "Policy, Power, and Politics")
Time: about 35 minutes
The question
Section 10.3 says that the benefits of burning carbon, the responsibility for past emissions, and the harm from climate change fall on different people. Is that true for two countries you choose? And which numbers should count when we ask who is responsible?
What to do
Choose one rich country and one poor one from these: for the rich one, the United States, the United Kingdom or the European Union; for the poor one, India, Bangladesh, Kenya or Ethiopia. (These are among the twelve countries on Pledges and Paths, so step 4 works for them.) This is easiest on a laptop.
- Each country's share of all the fossil CO₂ ever emitted. Open Our World in Data's table of the share of global cumulative CO₂ emissions (ourworldindata.org/grapher/share-of-cumulative-co2?tab=table). The 2025 column is each country's share of all the CO₂ emitted from fossil fuels and industry since 1750. Write it down for both countries.
- Each country's emissions per person today. Open the table of CO₂ emissions per person (ourworldindata.org/grapher/co-emissions-per-capita?tab=table). Write down the 2025 value for both, in tonnes of CO₂ a person.
- Each country's income per person. Open the table of GDP per person (ourworldindata.org/grapher/gdp-per-capita-worldbank?tab=table). Write down the 2025 value for both. It's in international dollars at 2021 prices, which allows for what money buys in each country.
- Each country's emissions since 1990, per person living there now. Open Pledges and Paths at https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/pledges/, choose each country in turn, and find the row "CO₂ from fossil fuels since 1990, per person living now".
- How vulnerable each country is. Open the ND-GAIN rankings (gain.nd.edu/our-work/country-index/rankings). Click "Vulnerability" above the table. Find both countries' 2024 scores. A higher score means more vulnerable: more exposed to climate change, more sensitive to it, and less able to adapt.
- Compare with the book. Look at Figure 10.2, whose maps A and B use the same kinds of numbers for every country.
What to hand in
- Three short answers: Q1 to Q3.
- One paragraph: Q4.
The questions
- Q1.
Give the five numbers from steps 1 to 5 for both of your countries, with their units and years. Name the countries.
(3 points)
- Q2.
How many times more CO₂ does a person in your rich country emit each year than a person in your poor one? How many times more has been emitted since 1990, per person living now? Why are the two ratios different?
(3 points)
- Q3.
ND-GAIN's vulnerability score combines exposure, sensitivity and the capacity to adapt. Which of those do you think does most to make your poor country more vulnerable than your rich one? Use one example from Section 10.3.
(2 points)
- Q4.
Section 10.3 says that "historical totals and current annual flows answer different questions about responsibility." In one paragraph: which of your numbers would you use to say who is responsible for climate change, and why? What would someone from the other country say? Use Figure 10.2's map C, of colonial rule, and say whether it changes your answer.
(4 points)