Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 10C: A lending map and a hot afternoon

Pages: Mapping Inequality, from the University of Richmond (dsl.richmond.edu/panorama/redlining), and the Tree Equity Score National Explorer, from American Forests (treeequityscore.org/map), both listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/

Chapter: 10, "Climate Justice and Ethics"

Time: about 40 minutes

The question

Section 10.1 says that colors drawn on a federal map in the 1930s still help decide who swelters on a summer afternoon. Can you follow that chain, from a lending grade to the shade on a street, in a city you choose?

What to do

A note before you start: the 1930s appraisers' area descriptions you'll read in step 2 use the racist and anti-immigrant language of their time. That language is the evidence; it's why the grades were what they were.

  1. Choose a city. Open Mapping Inequality (dsl.richmond.edu/panorama/redlining) and choose a city with "Select City". The federal government made these maps for almost every major US city in the 1930s, including New Haven, whose 1937 map is in Section 10.1. Choose one you know, if you can.
  2. Choose two neighborhoods and read what the appraisers wrote. On the map, choose one neighborhood graded A (green) or B (blue), and one graded D (red). Click each to open its area description. Write down its grade and number (such as D5), and a phrase or two from its "Clarifying remarks", "Favorable influences" and "Detrimental influences".
  3. Open today's map. Open the Tree Equity Score National Explorer (treeequityscore.org/map) and search for your city. Click "Layers", then "Redlining" under "Environmental indicators", and close the panel. The 1930s grades now color the map. Find your two neighborhoods.
  4. Read today's numbers. Click a shaded area that lies well inside your A or B neighborhood. The panel on the left describes that census block group: write down its tree canopy cover, its heat disparity, and its share of people in poverty and of people of color. Do the same inside your D neighborhood.
  5. Find out what "heat disparity" means. Open Tree Equity Score's methodology page (treeequityscore.org/methodology) and read the paragraph on heat disparity.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    Name your city and your two neighborhoods, with their grades. Quote a phrase or two that the appraisers wrote about each. What did they count as favorable, and what as detrimental?

    (2 points)

  2. Q2.

    Give today's numbers for your two block groups: tree canopy cover, heat disparity, people in poverty and people of color. By how much do the two differ in canopy and in heat disparity?

    (2 points)

  3. Q3.

    What does Tree Equity Score's "heat disparity" measure? Is it the temperature of the air you'd feel walking down the street?

    (2 points)

  4. Q4.

    In one paragraph, trace the chain from your D neighborhood's grade in the 1930s to its shade and heat today. Name at least three links in the chain, using Section 10.1.

    (3 points)

  5. Q5.

    Is it fair to say that the 1930s map caused what you see today? In one paragraph, give one reason to be careful with your comparison, and one piece of evidence that the pattern is more than a coincidence.

    (3 points)