Exercise 11B: Babies, income and catching up
Page: Gapminder Tools (gapminder.org/tools), the Gapminder Foundation's free bubble charts of the world's countries since 1800, listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/
Chapter: 11, "Economics of Fire"
Time: about 45 minutes
The question
The first factor in the Kaya identity is the number of people. Section 11.2 says population growth is no longer the main driver of rising emissions, because families get smaller as countries develop. Watch it happen, country by country: did family size follow income, and did poorer countries catch up?
What to do
Gapminder Tools draws every country as a bubble: its size is the country's population, its color the world region. It works best on a computer or tablet. It also runs on a phone held sideways, where the list of countries is behind the "Find" button.
- Open Gapminder Tools (gapminder.org/tools). It opens on "Bubbles", with life expectancy against income in the latest year. The bottom axis, "GDP per capita", is what the book calls income per person, in the same units as the book's figure "Child survival and family size differ sharply across income levels" (11.2): constant 2021 international dollars, adjusted for purchasing power. It's a logarithmic axis: each step to the right doubles the income.
- Put babies on the side. Click the words "Life expectancy" on the left axis and choose "Babies per woman". That's the total fertility rate of 11.2: the number of children a woman would have at that year's birth rates.
- Choose four countries. In the list headed "Select" on the right, tick India, Nigeria, South Korea and USA. To read a country's numbers, point at its name in the list: its babies per woman appears on the left axis, its income per person on the bottom axis, and its population in the "Size" box. (Don't click a bubble to read it: that selects or unselects it.)
- Go back to 1960. Drag the round handle of the time slider at the bottom to the left until the big gray year behind the bubbles reads 1960. Write down each country's babies per woman, income per person and population.
- Play it forward. Press the play button at the bottom left. The four countries leave trails. When it stops at the latest year, write down the same numbers again.
- Look at the crowd. In the latest year, find two or three countries with about the same income per person as Nigeria. Point at their bubbles to read their names and numbers.
- Now put child deaths across. Click the words "GDP per capita" on the bottom axis and choose "Child mortality": how many children of every 1,000 born die before age five. Drag the time back to 1960 and play it forward again. Watch which way each trail moves first: left (fewer children dying) or down (fewer babies).
What to hand in
- A table: Q1.
- Four short answers, a few sentences each: Q2 to Q5.
The questions
- Q1.
Make a table of the four countries in 1960 and in the latest year: babies per woman, income per person and population. Give the latest year.
(4 points)
- Q2.
Does income alone set family size? Use two pieces of evidence. First, the trails: at about what income did South Korea, and then India, fall to the replacement level of about 2.1 babies per woman, and in what years? Second, the crowd: name two countries with about Nigeria's income today, and give their babies per woman.
(3 points)
- Q3.
The book describes the demographic transition: "Death rates fall first, especially the terrible risk of losing a child. About a generation later, birth rates fall just as steeply" (11.2). With child mortality across (step 7), do the trails of Nigeria and India show it? Describe each trail, with numbers.
(3 points)
- Q4.
India's babies per woman fell below replacement around 2020. Did its population stop growing? Use your table and section 11.2 to explain what's happening, and then say what falling family size does to the first Kaya factor, population, and why population growth is no longer the main driver of rising emissions.
(3 points)
- Q5.
Is the world catching up? For South Korea, India and Nigeria, divide the USA's income per person by the country's, in 1960 and in the latest year. Which have converged on the USA, which hasn't, and what does section 11.3 say can hold a country back?
(3 points)