Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 12A: Keeping the lights on

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/grid/, "Keeping the Lights On: A Year of Sun, Wind and Demand"

Chapter: 12, "Reinventing Fire"

Time: about 40 minutes

The question

Could a real power grid run a whole year on clean electricity, and which of Chapter 12's five tools does the most to close the gap?

What to do

  1. Start with the grid as it was. Open the page. It's MISO, the Midwest grid, with what it had in 2025. Read the table "The year".
  2. Try solar alone. Set "Wind turbines (GW)" and "Clean firm power (GW)" to 0, and "Solar panels (GW)" to 150. Read how much clean power meets, and how much is thrown away. Look at a week in July.
  3. Mix in wind, then store energy. Set the wind turbines to 150 GW. Then set "Batteries (GWh)" to 400. Press "The worst week" and look at what the wind does.
  4. Send it far. With 150 GW of each and 400 GWh of batteries, try each choice under "Where the solar and wind are".
  5. Add clean firm power. Go back to "Build it all here" and set the clean firm power to 15 GW.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    With MISO as it was in 2025, what share of the year's electricity use did clean power meet? Give your answer as a percentage.

    Answer in percent.

  2. Q2.

    With 150 GW of solar panels and no wind or clean firm power, what share of the clean power made is thrown away? Give your answer as a percentage.

    Answer in percent.

  3. Q3.

    With 150 GW of solar, 150 GW of wind, no clean firm power and 400 GWh of batteries, what is the biggest shortfall in one hour? Give your answer in gigawatts.

    Answer in GW.

  4. Q4.

    Keep those settings and build half the solar and wind in California's weather. What share of the year's use does clean power meet? Give your answer as a percentage.

    Answer in percent.

  5. Q5.

    Build it all here again, and add 15 GW of clean firm power. What share of the year's use does clean power meet? Give your answer as a percentage.

    Answer in percent.

  6. Q6.

    With 150 GW of solar, 150 GW of wind and 400 GWh of batteries, press "The worst week". In three or four sentences: what is the weather doing that week, and why can't four-hour batteries cover it? Which of the other tools would help most, and why?

    (4 points)

  7. Q7.

    Wiring in California's weather helps much more than wiring in the Mid-Atlantic's, even though the Mid-Atlantic is next door. Use Chapter 12's idea of the size of weather systems to explain why in three or four sentences. Then name one thing the page leaves out that would make a line to California harder in real life.

    (3 points)