Exercise 12B: How one country makes its electricity
Page: Ember's Electricity Data Explorer (ember-energy.org/data/electricity-data-explorer), from the energy think tank Ember, listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/
Chapter: 12, "Reinventing Fire"
Time: about 45 minutes
The question
Section 12.2 says that clean electricity is now the cheapest electricity, and that coal has collapsed in much of the developed world. What does that look like, year by year, in a rich country and in two countries that are still getting richer? And when a country's share of clean power goes up, do its emissions have to go down?
What to do
Ember collects every country's electricity statistics into one free, open dataset. Its explorer runs in the browser of a computer, a tablet or a phone, but its charts are small on a phone, so a computer is easier. To read a number, hold the pointer over the chart (or tap it on a phone): a box shows the year and the value.
- Learn the controls. Open the explorer (ember-energy.org/data/electricity-data-explorer). If a box about cookies appears, you can close it; the explorer works either way. Scroll down to the chart. Above it are four controls you'll use: - "Select dataset": keep it on "Electricity generation" for now. - "Metric": "Absolute value" gives terawatt-hours (TWh, a billion kilowatt-hours); "% Share" gives each source's share of all the electricity the country made. - "Geography": click "Countries or economies", type a name in the box "Type here to filter", and click the country. - "Source": "All electricity sources" stacks every source; below it you can pick a group, such as "Wind and solar", or one source, such as "Coal".
- Check the book on Germany. Choose Germany, "% Share", and Source "Wind and solar". Under the chart, click "combined" so wind and solar make one line. Read the share in 2000, 2015 and 2025. (This address opens Germany's shares: ember-energy.org/data/electricity-data-explorer/?entity=Germany&metric=pct_share.)
- Watch Britain give up coal. Choose United Kingdom, "% Share", and "All electricity sources". Read the share of coal, gas, wind and solar in 2015 and in 2025.
- Compare two countries that are still getting richer. Do the same for Chile and for India: the share of coal, gas, solar and wind in 2015 and in 2025. If a thin band is hard to hover over, choose that one source under "Source".
- Read the emissions. Change "Select dataset" to "Carbon emissions intensity". It shows the grams of greenhouse gas, counted as CO₂-equivalent (CO₂e), for each kilowatt-hour of the country's electricity. Read it for 2015 and 2025, for the United Kingdom, Chile and India. (This address opens Chile's: ember-energy.org/data/electricity-data-explorer/?entity=Chile&data=co2_intensity.)
- Count the coal, not just its share. Go back to "Electricity generation", choose India and "Absolute value". Read India's total electricity in 2015 and 2025 (Source "All electricity sources", "combined"), then its coal and its wind and solar, in TWh.
What to hand in
- Four short answers: Q1 to Q4.
- Two paragraphs: Q5 and Q6.
The questions
- Q1.
Section 12.2 says that wind and solar gave Germany "almost 45% of its electricity in 2025, up from less than 2% in 2000". What shares does the explorer give for 2000, 2015 and 2025? Does the book's sentence hold?
(2 points)
- Q2.
Give the United Kingdom's shares of coal, gas, wind and solar in 2015 and 2025. Coal nearly vanished. Which sources took its place?
(3 points)
- Q3.
Fill in a table for Chile and India: the share of coal, gas, solar and wind in 2015 and 2025, and the carbon emissions intensity (grams of CO₂e per kilowatt-hour) in 2015 and 2025. Add the United Kingdom's intensity in both years.
(3 points)
- Q4.
Which of the two countries, Chile or India, changed its electricity faster from 2015 to 2025, and how? Use the shares and the intensities.
(3 points)
- Q5.
In one paragraph: India's share of electricity from coal fell between 2015 and 2025. Did India burn less coal for electricity? Use the totals in terawatt-hours from step 6 to explain. Then say what has to happen before India's coal burning, and its emissions from electricity, start to fall, and why that matters for stopping warming.
(4 points)
- Q6.
In one paragraph: Table 12.1 gives each source's lifecycle emissions in grams of CO₂e per kilowatt-hour: 820 for coal and 490 for gas. Use those two numbers and the 2025 shares of coal and gas to estimate the emissions intensity of the United Kingdom, Chile and India. (For example, a country that made half its electricity from gas and none from coal would get 0.5 × 490 ≈ 245 g/kWh from gas.) How close do your estimates come to the explorer's? Give two reasons the explorer's numbers are higher.
(3 points)