Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 13A: The mop and the bill

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/removal-bill/, "The Mop and the Bill: What It Costs to Take Carbon Back Out of the Air"

Chapter: 13, "Cleaning Up the Mess"

Time: about 30 to 40 minutes

The question

What would it cost, in dollars and in energy, to take enough carbon back out of the air to matter?

What to do

  1. Open the page and read the table. It opens on Chapter 13's own example: 1 GtC captured and stored each year for 50 years, at $100 for each ton of CO₂. Find the bill, how far the CO₂ in the air falls, and how much the planet cools. Then look at the graph. The band between the two lines is the carbon that comes back out of the land and ocean.
  2. Try today's machines. Press "Direct air capture today". Read the two rows of the table that begin "At this price", and the row "The energy each year".
  3. Price the faucet instead. Press "Back to where the page opened". Set "Carbon captured and stored (GtC a year)" to 1, "For how many years" to 1 and "Price for each ton of CO₂ ($)" to 20. The bill is now what it would cost to keep 1 GtC out of the air in the first place, at $20 a ton. The IPCC found that options under $20 a ton could make more than half of the cuts that would halve the world's emissions by 2030 (Chapter 13, section 13.5).
  4. Look at the bars. Press "Back to where the page opened" again. Compare your bill with the bar for dimming the Sun, and read what the About tab says about that bar under "Where the numbers come from".

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    With the page as it opens (1 GtC a year for 50 years, at $100 for each ton of CO₂), what is the bill? Give your answer in trillions of dollars.

    Answer in trillion dollars.

  2. Q2.

    With the same settings, by how many parts per million does the CO₂ in the air fall?

    Answer in ppm.

  3. Q3.

    Press "Direct air capture today" ($1,000 for each ton of CO₂). At that price, what does it cost to lower the CO₂ in the air by 1 ppm? Give your answer in trillions of dollars.

    Answer in trillion dollars.

  4. Q4.

    Still with "Direct air capture today", capturing 1 GtC a year: the capture uses as much energy as what percentage of all the electricity the world made in 2025?

    Answer in percent.

  5. Q5.

    What would it cost to keep 1 GtC out of the air in the first place, by cutting emissions at $20 for each ton of CO₂? Give your answer in billions of dollars. Then say how many times more it costs to capture the same carbon afterward with today's direct air capture, at $1,000 a ton.

    Answer in billion dollars.

  6. Q6.

    The graph has a band between its two lines. In three or four sentences: what is that carbon, where does it come from, and what does it do to the price of lowering the CO₂ in the air by 1 ppm? Why doesn't it double the price of a tenth of a degree as well?

    (4 points)

  7. Q7.

    The bar for dimming the Sun is far too small to see beside your bill. Give two reasons from Chapter 13 why the book still calls dimming the Sun a band-aid. Then say in a sentence what the chapter says to do first.

    (3 points)