Exercise 14A: A century of damage, priced today
Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/discounting/, "Climate Damage: Compounding vs Discounting"
Chapter: 14, "Planetary Prosperity"
Time: about 25 minutes
The question
A century of climate damage is worth how much today? And who decides?
What to do
- Open the page. It opens on Box 14.1 of Chapter 14: income per person starts at $10,000 a year and grows at 2.50% a year in a cooler world and 2.49% in a hotter one. Read the summary under the graph. It gives the damage added up over 100 years, not discounted, and its value today, discounted at 4.5% a year.
- Press the three buttons under the discount rate, one at a time: "Stern's 1.4%", "The experts' median, 2%" and "Nordhaus's 5.5%". After each one, read the value today in the summary.
- Turn the discounting off. Set "Discount rate (% a year)" to 0.
- Make the damage bigger. Press "Back to the book's example". Set "How much slower a hotter world grows (percentage points)" to 0.1, and press "The experts' median, 2%".
What to hand in
- Six numbers, in dollars a person: Q1 to Q6.
- One short answer, a few sentences: Q7.
The questions
- Q1.
With the page as it opens (Box 14.1: discounted at 4.5% a year over 100 years), what is the damage worth today? Give your answer in dollars a person.
Answer in dollars a person.
- Q2.
At Stern's discount rate, 1.4% a year, what is the same damage worth today?
Answer in dollars a person.
- Q3.
At the median discount rate that more than 200 experts recommended, 2% a year, what is it worth today?
Answer in dollars a person.
- Q4.
At Nordhaus's discount rate, 5.5% a year, what is it worth today?
Answer in dollars a person.
- Q5.
With no discounting at all (a discount rate of 0), what does the hotter world lose over the century, added up?
Answer in dollars a person.
- Q6.
Go back to the book's example. Make the hotter world grow 0.1 percentage point more slowly instead of 0.01, and discount at the experts' median, 2%. What is the damage worth today?
Answer in dollars a person.
- Q7.
Your answers to Q2, Q3 and Q4 come from the same damage. In four or five sentences: whose argument does each rate stand for, and on what grounds? What does each say about how much it would be worth spending this year, for each person, to avoid the damage? Why does Chapter 14 call the discount rate an ethical choice as well as a technical one?
(4 points)