Exercise 14B: What moves the social cost of carbon
Page: the Social Cost of Carbon Explorer (rff.org/publications/data-tools/scc-explorer), from Resources for the Future, listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/
Chapter: 14, "Planetary Prosperity" (with Chapter 7, "Climate Scenarios")
Time: about 40 minutes
The question
The social cost of carbon is the damage done by one more ton of CO₂, added up over all the years it keeps the world warmer and discounted to today (14.3). Even one economist's estimates with one model spread by a factor of more than ten. Which choices move it most?
What to do
The Social Cost of Carbon Explorer, from Resources for the Future (RFF), shows how the choices inside one model, RFF's open-source GIVE model, change its answer. It works on a phone, but it's easier on a computer.
- Open the explorer. Open the page (rff.org/publications/data-tools/scc-explorer) and scroll down to the tool, "RFF Social Cost of Carbon Explorer". Across the top are four modules, the four steps of the model: ① Socioeconomic (people, income and emissions), ② Climate, ③ Damages and ④ Discounting. Under them, "Output" is set to "Social Cost of CO₂".
- Read the starting numbers. The right-hand graph, "Distribution of 2020 Values", is for a ton of CO₂ emitted in 2020. The model was run 10,000 times with different values for the things nobody knows exactly, and the bars count the runs. The dollar figure at the top of each set of bars is the average of the runs. The tool starts with two sets of future people and incomes switched on: RFF's own projections (RFF-SPs) and the IPCC's SSP2, the middle-of-the-road pathway from Chapter 7. Write down both dollar figures.
- Change the discount rate. At the top right, under "Data Comparison", click "Discount Rates". The tool now shows RFF-SPs at a 2% discount rate and at 3%. Write down both dollar figures.
- Change the damages. Click "Damages". The tool now shows three ways of turning a warmer climate into lost dollars: the curve from Nordhaus's DICE model, the curve of Howard and Sterner, and RFF's own (Rennert et al.), which adds up damage to health, farming, energy use and coasts. Write down the three dollar figures at 2%. Then click "3%" under Discount Rate and write down the three again.
- Change the future people. Click "Socioeconomics", and make sure "2%" is chosen. Click SSP1, SSP3 and SSP5 to switch them on too, so that five sets of bars show. Write down the five dollar figures.
- Look at the Climate module. Click each of its three menus, Temperature, Sea Level and Ocean pH. Note how many choices each one offers.
What to hand in
- Short answers: Q1 to Q4.
- One paragraph: Q5.
The questions
- Q1.
Report the two starting dollar figures (step 2). In one or two sentences, say what the RFF-SPs figure means: the cost of what, emitted when, in what units? Then compare it with the US Environmental Protection Agency's 2023 estimate in Table 14.1, and say what discount rate both used.
(3 points)
- Q2.
Report the social cost of carbon at 2% and at 3% (step 3). By what factor did one percentage point change it? Chapter 14 says Stern argued for a discount rate of about 1.4% a year and Nordhaus for about 5.5%. Without the tool, which way would each move the number, and would the change be small or large? Explain why one point of discount rate matters so much, using what discounting does to damage a century or more away.
(4 points)
- Q3.
Report the three damage approaches at 2% and at 3% (step 4). How far apart are the three at 2%, as a factor from lowest to highest? Compare that with the factor you found in Q2. On this tool, which choice moved the social cost of carbon more: the damage approach, or one point of discount rate?
(3 points)
- Q4.
Report the five figures from step 5. SSP3, Chapter 7's Regional Rivalry, is a high-emissions world (its CMIP6 experiment is SSP3-7.0), yet here it gives the lowest social cost of carbon. SSP5, the other high-emissions world, gives the highest. Use Chapter 7's figure of population and income in the SSPs (Figure 7.1) to explain the difference. What does this say about whose losses a number in dollars counts most?
(4 points)
- Q5.
In step 6, how many choices did the Climate module offer? In one paragraph: the tool lets you change the future people, the damages and the discount rate, and in this exercise all three moved the number. Which of these choices is mostly a question for science, and which mostly a question of values? Use Chapter 14's comparison of the spread in estimates of warming per doubling of CO₂ (a factor of less than two) with the spread in economists' social costs of carbon (a factor of more than ten). Where does that larger spread come from?
(4 points)