Exercise 15A: Three levers
Page: En-ROADS (en-roads.climateinteractive.org), Climate Interactive and MIT Sloan's free climate policy simulator, listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/
Chapter: 15, "Policy, Power, and Politics" (with Chapter 14, "Planetary Prosperity")
Time: about 45 minutes
The question
Governments have three kinds of tool for cutting emissions: a price on carbon, rules, and public money (Table 15.1). How far does each one go on its own, who pays for it, and why would a government use more than one?
What to do
En-ROADS is a model of the whole world's energy, land and climate, from Climate Interactive and the MIT Sloan School of Management. You move sliders that stand for policies, and it shows the warming that follows. It runs in the browser of a computer or tablet, not on a phone.
- Open En-ROADS and set up the graphs. Open En-ROADS (en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html) and click "Get Started". The big number on the right is the warming in 2100, above the late 1800s. Click the title of the left graph, type "Revenue" in the search box, and choose "Revenue & Cost from Energy Taxes & Subsidies". Do the same for the right graph, and choose "Average Price of Energy to Consumers". In each graph, the black line is the baseline, the world with no new policy.
- Write down the baseline. With every slider at "status quo", write down the warming in 2100.
- Pull the first lever: a price. Drag the Carbon Price slider all the way to the right, to "very high". Write down the warming in 2100, and look at both graphs: who collects money, and what happens to the price of energy? (If you get lost, this address opens this setting: en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?p39=250.)
- Start again. Choose Simulation, then Reset Policies.
- Pull the second lever: rules. These are standards: the law says what may be built or sold, and nobody pays a tax or gets a subsidy. - Drag both Energy Efficiency sliders, for Transport and for Buildings and Industry, all the way to the right. In En-ROADS these stand for efficiency standards, like fuel economy rules and building codes. - Click the words "Carbon Price". The panel that opens is called "Carbon Pricing and Energy Standards". Scroll down to "Clean electricity standard", switch on "Use clean electricity standard", and type 100 in the box for "Target % electricity from qualifying sources". Close the panel with the × at its top right. - Click the word "Electrification" under Transport. Find "Fuel-powered transport sales limit" and type 0 in its box: after a phase-in, no new gasoline or diesel cars, trucks or trains may be sold. Close the panel. Click "Electrification" under Buildings and Industry and do the same for "Fuel-powered equipment sales limit". - Write down the warming in 2100, and look at both graphs. (This address opens these settings: en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?p47=3&p50=3&p245=1&p247=100&p53=0&p55=0.)
- Start again (Simulation, then Reset Policies).
- Pull the third lever: public money. Drag four sliders all the way to the right: Renewables and Nuclear (subsidies that pay part of the cost of building them), and both Electrification sliders (subsidies that pay part of the price of an electric car or heat pump). Then drag New Zero-Carbon to "huge breakthrough", which stands for public money spent on research that pays off. Write down the warming in 2100, and look at both graphs. (This address opens these settings: en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?p520=-100&p521=-100&p373=50&p375=50&p35=2.)
- Pull all three at once. Without resetting, add back the very high carbon price and the rules from step 5. Write down the warming.
- Then go after the other gases. Drag Deforestation, Agricultural Emissions, and Waste and Leakage all the way to the left. Write down the warming again.
What to hand in
- Four short answers: Q1 to Q4.
- One paragraph: Q5.
The questions
- Q1.
Report the warming in 2100 for the baseline and for each lever on its own: the price (step 3), the rules (step 5) and the public money (step 7). Which lever went furthest on its own? Give the version number of En-ROADS you used: it's at the bottom right of the screen.
(3 points)
- Q2.
Who pays for each lever? Use the two graphs: the revenue the government collects from energy taxes, the money it spends on subsidies, and the price of energy to consumers. Answer in two or three sentences for each lever.
(3 points)
- Q3.
Report the warming with all three levers at once (step 8), and then with the other gases too (step 9). Add up how far each lever on its own brought warming down from the baseline. Is the sum bigger or smaller than what the three did together? Why?
(3 points)
- Q4.
En-ROADS applies every policy to the whole world at once. Real carbon prices are set country by country. What does the free-rider problem predict about a carbon price that one country or one group of countries sets on its own? How does the European Union's border charge try to answer it?
(3 points)
- Q5.
Economists like a carbon price best (15.1), and in En-ROADS the rules went further. But a model counts tons and degrees, not votes. In one paragraph: using what Chapter 15 says about the political fates of carbon prices, and about who sees the cost of each lever, which mix of levers would you expect to last through elections, and why? What would you want to know that En-ROADS can't tell you?
(4 points)