Exercise 15C: Your state and your city
Pages: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/pledges/?c=USA, "Pledges and Paths"; and three outside pages: the map of state greenhouse gas targets (c2es.org/document/greenhouse-gas-emissions-targets) from the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions (C2ES), the US Energy Information Administration's (EIA) state CO₂ tables (eia.gov/environment/emissions/state), and your own city's climate plan
Chapter: 15, "Policy, Power, and Politics" (with Chapter 11, "Economics of Fire")
Time: about 40 minutes
The question
Section 15.4 says that states and cities have often moved faster than their national governments. Is that true where you live? What has your state promised, what has your city promised, and how do their promises and their progress compare with the country's?
What to do
Choose a US state and a city in it: where you live, where you grew up, or one you'd like to know about. (If you live outside the United States, use your own country, a province or region, and a city, and ask your instructor which sources to use.)
- The country's goal. Open Pledges and Paths at https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/pledges/?c=USA. Read the United States' pledge for 2035 under the Paris Agreement, in its own words, and the note under it.
- The state's goal. Open the C2ES map of state greenhouse gas targets (c2es.org/document/greenhouse-gas-emissions-targets) and click your state. Write down each target: how much, below which year, by when, and whether it's in law (statutory) or set by a governor (executive). Many states have no target at all; if yours has none, write that down.
- The state's emissions. Open the EIA state CO₂ tables (eia.gov/environment/emissions/state). Under "Total CO2 emissions estimates from energy consumption by source", open the HTML table for 1960–2024. It opens for the whole United States: write down the total for 2005 and for 2024 (the last column, in thousand metric tons of CO₂). Then choose your state with "Change state/territory" at the top, and write down its totals for 2005 and 2024. Work out the percentage change for each.
- The city's goal. Search the web for your city's climate action plan or climate dashboard. Write down its goal, its base year, and the latest progress it reports. If your city has no plan, choose the nearest city that does, and say so. (An example: Fort Collins, Colorado, aims for 80% below 2005 by 2030, and reported in March 2026 that its 2024 emissions were 28% below 2005, Figure 15.6.)
- Read the fine print. Read the notes under the EIA table, and look at what your state's and city's goals count: all greenhouse gases, or CO₂ from energy?
What to hand in
- Four short answers: Q1 to Q4.
- Two paragraphs: Q5 and Q6.
The questions
- Q1.
What did the United States pledge for 2035, and where does that pledge stand now? By how much did US energy CO₂ change from 2005 to 2024, in EIA's table?
(2 points)
- Q2.
What are your state's greenhouse gas targets? For each, give how much, below which year, by when, and whether it's in law or set by the governor. If your state has no target, say so.
(2 points)
- Q3.
What were your state's energy CO₂ emissions in 2005 and in 2024, in EIA's table, and by what percentage did they change? Compare that with the change for the whole country (Q1).
(2 points)
- Q4.
What is your city's climate goal, and what progress does it report? Name the plan or page you used.
(2 points)
- Q5.
Is your state on the way to its goal? Before you answer, say whether your comparison is fair. In one paragraph: what do EIA's numbers count, and what do the state's and city's goals count? Name at least two ways they differ, and say how each could make your state look better or worse than it is.
(4 points)
- Q6.
Section 15.4 says that local and regional climate policy has been more aggressive and more successful than international policy, the opposite of the textbook prediction. In one paragraph: does your state and city's record support that, or not? Give one reason from the chapter why a state or city might move faster than its country, and one reason it might not.
(3 points)