Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 15D: A supermajority, district by district

Page: the Yale Climate Opinion Maps 2025 (climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us), from the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication, listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/

Chapter: 15, "Policy, Power, and Politics"

Time: about 40 minutes

The question

Section 15.5 says that large majorities of people in the United States support strong climate policy, and that most people don't know it. Is that true in your own congressional district? If the support is there, why don't popular policies sail through?

What to do

The Yale Climate Opinion Maps estimate what adults think about global warming in every state, congressional district, metro area and county of the United States, from 33 national surveys of more than 34,000 people, 2008 to 2025 (Figure 15.7 is drawn from them). They work best on a laptop or tablet.

  1. Guess first. Before you open the maps, write down your guesses: what percentage of adults in your congressional district (a) think global warming is happening, (b) support moving the US economy from fossil fuels to 100% clean energy by 2050, and (c) support requiring fossil fuel companies to pay a carbon tax? Don't change your guesses later.
  2. Open the maps. Open the Yale Climate Opinion Maps 2025 (climatecommunication.yale.edu/visualizations-data/ycom-us). Scroll down to the map. Use "Select Question" to choose a question; the title gives the national average.
  3. Read the nation. For each of these questions, write down the national average: "Global warming is happening"; "U.S. economy transition from fossil fuels to 100% clean energy by 2050"; "Require fossil fuel companies to pay a carbon tax"; "Regulate CO2 as a pollutant"; "Provide tax rebates for energy-efficient vehicles or solar panels"; "Fund research into renewable energy sources"; "Build wind farms in your local area"; and "Discuss global warming with family and friends".
  4. Find your district. Choose your state with "Select a State", then click "Cong. Districts" above the map and click your district. (If you don't know your district, any district in a place you know will do; say which.) Scroll down through the bar graphs for your district, and find the same questions as in step 3.
  5. Find the other end. Keep the question on 100% clean energy by 2050. Click "States" to see the whole country, then "Cong. Districts", and find a district, in any state, that the map colors blue: below half. (On this map, blue is below half and yellow to red is above; Figure 15.7 uses brown for below half.) Click it and read its bar graphs too.
  6. Read how the maps are made. Click the "Methodology" tab above the map and read the first part.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    Give your three guesses from step 1, and the map's estimates for your district on the same three questions. Name your state and district. How far off was each guess, and in which direction?

    (2 points)

  2. Q2.

    Give the national averages for the eight questions in step 3. Which of Chapter 15's three kinds of tool (prices, rules and public money; Table 15.1) do the policy questions stand for, and which gets the most support?

    (3 points)

  3. Q3.

    Name the low-support district you found in step 5. Give its estimates for the same three questions as in Q1. Is "global warming is happening" below half there too?

    (2 points)

  4. Q4.

    These numbers are estimates, not a poll of each district. In one paragraph: how does the Yale team get an estimate for a district where it may have surveyed only a few dozen people? What does that mean for how you should read your district's numbers?

    (3 points)

  5. Q5.

    Section 15.5 asks: if about two-thirds of adults support a transition to clean energy, how is it that climate policy is seen as bitterly divided, and why do popular policies stall? In one paragraph, answer using your numbers and at least two reasons from the chapter. Then say what the "discuss" number (step 3) has to do with it.

    (4 points)