Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 4A: How sensitive?

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/forcing-feedback/, "The Push and the Response: Forcing, Feedback and Warming"

Chapter: 4, "How Climate Changes"

Time: about 40 minutes

The question

How much does the world warm for a doubling of CO₂, and why can't the warming we've measured settle the answer on its own?

What to do

  1. Work out the baseline by hand. On the About tab, read steps 3 and 4. With no feedbacks at all, the gain is 0.
  2. Open "2. Feedback". It opens with every gain at the IPCC's central value. Read the line under the drawings: it gives the warming from doubling CO₂. Then move "Clouds" to its lowest setting and read it again.
  3. Match the past two ways. Press "Back to the opening settings" and open "3. Response". Set "Clouds" to 0 and "Heat passing down to the deep ocean (W/m² for each °C the surface is warmer than the deep)" to 0.2. Read the line under the graph: the typical difference between the model and the measurements. Then set "Clouds" to 0.3 and the deep ocean to 1.5, and read it again.
  4. Look ahead. For each of the two settings in step 3, open "4. The future" and read the model's average warming for 2081 to 2100 under SSP2-4.5.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    With no feedbacks at all, how much would doubling CO₂ warm the world in the end? Work it out with steps 3 and 4 of the About tab.

    Answer in °C.

  2. Q2.

    With every gain at the IPCC's central value, as the page opens, how much does doubling CO₂ warm the world in the end?

    Answer in °C.

  3. Q3.

    Move "Clouds" to its lowest setting, −0.15, with the other gains as they open. How much does doubling CO₂ warm the world now?

    Answer in °C.

  4. Q4.

    On "3. Response", with clouds at 0 and the deep ocean at 0.2, what is the typical difference between the model and the measurements over 1850 to 2019?

    Answer in °C.

  5. Q5.

    With clouds at 0.3 and the deep ocean at 1.5, what is the typical difference now?

    Answer in °C.

  6. Q6.

    With clouds at 0 and the deep ocean at 0.2, what is the model's average warming for 2081 to 2100 under SSP2-4.5, above 1850 to 1900?

    Answer in °C.

  7. Q7.

    With clouds at 0.3 and the deep ocean at 1.5?

    Answer in °C.

  8. Q8.

    The two settings in Q4 and Q5 match the measured warming about equally well, but one warms 2.5 °C for doubled CO₂ and the other 6.4 °C. In four or five sentences, explain how both can match the past, why they part ways in the future, and how Chapter 4 says scientists narrow the range anyway.

    (4 points)