Exercise 4A: How sensitive?
Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/forcing-feedback/, "The Push and the Response: Forcing, Feedback and Warming"
Chapter: 4, "How Climate Changes"
Time: about 40 minutes
The question
How much does the world warm for a doubling of CO₂, and why can't the warming we've measured settle the answer on its own?
What to do
- Work out the baseline by hand. On the About tab, read steps 3 and 4. With no feedbacks at all, the gain is 0.
- Open "2. Feedback". It opens with every gain at the IPCC's central value. Read the line under the drawings: it gives the warming from doubling CO₂. Then move "Clouds" to its lowest setting and read it again.
- Match the past two ways. Press "Back to the opening settings" and open "3. Response". Set "Clouds" to 0 and "Heat passing down to the deep ocean (W/m² for each °C the surface is warmer than the deep)" to 0.2. Read the line under the graph: the typical difference between the model and the measurements. Then set "Clouds" to 0.3 and the deep ocean to 1.5, and read it again.
- Look ahead. For each of the two settings in step 3, open "4. The future" and read the model's average warming for 2081 to 2100 under SSP2-4.5.
What to hand in
- Seven numbers, in °C: Q1 to Q7.
- One short answer, a few sentences: Q8.
The questions
- Q1.
With no feedbacks at all, how much would doubling CO₂ warm the world in the end? Work it out with steps 3 and 4 of the About tab.
Answer in °C.
- Q2.
With every gain at the IPCC's central value, as the page opens, how much does doubling CO₂ warm the world in the end?
Answer in °C.
- Q3.
Move "Clouds" to its lowest setting, −0.15, with the other gains as they open. How much does doubling CO₂ warm the world now?
Answer in °C.
- Q4.
On "3. Response", with clouds at 0 and the deep ocean at 0.2, what is the typical difference between the model and the measurements over 1850 to 2019?
Answer in °C.
- Q5.
With clouds at 0.3 and the deep ocean at 1.5, what is the typical difference now?
Answer in °C.
- Q6.
With clouds at 0 and the deep ocean at 0.2, what is the model's average warming for 2081 to 2100 under SSP2-4.5, above 1850 to 1900?
Answer in °C.
- Q7.
With clouds at 0.3 and the deep ocean at 1.5?
Answer in °C.
- Q8.
The two settings in Q4 and Q5 match the measured warming about equally well, but one warms 2.5 °C for doubled CO₂ and the other 6.4 °C. In four or five sentences, explain how both can match the past, why they part ways in the future, and how Chapter 4 says scientists narrow the range anyway.
(4 points)