Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 5A: Sensitivity from deep time

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/phanerozoic/, "Hothouses and Icehouses: 485 Million Years of CO₂ and Temperature"

Chapter: 5, "Past Climate Change"

Time: about 30 minutes

The question

If we compare a hothouse world with an icehouse world, how much warmer was the hothouse for each doubling of CO₂? Is that the number to expect from our own CO₂?

What to do

  1. Open the page. "Over time" draws the world's average temperature and CO₂ for every stage of the last 485 million years. Click or tap a stage to read its numbers under the graph. The bold line is the middle estimate, and the bands show how uncertain it is.
  2. Find a hothouse. Click the Ypresian, in the Paleogene, about 48 to 56 million years ago (zoom in, or use "Jump to"). Write down its temperature and CO₂.
  3. Find an icehouse. Click the Upper Pleistocene, the stage of the last ice age, ending 11,700 years ago. Write down its temperature and CO₂.
  4. Compare. Work out how many times CO₂ doubled from the icehouse to the hothouse, and the warming for each doubling.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    What was the world's average temperature in the Ypresian (middle estimate)? Give your answer in °C.

    Answer in °C.

  2. Q2.

    And its CO₂ (middle estimate), in ppm?

    Answer in ppm.

  3. Q3.

    What was the world's average temperature in the Upper Pleistocene? Give your answer in °C.

    Answer in °C.

  4. Q4.

    And its CO₂, in ppm?

    Answer in ppm.

  5. Q5.

    From the Upper Pleistocene to the Ypresian, how much warmer was it for each doubling of CO₂? Give your answer in °C per doubling.

    Answer in °C per doubling.

  6. Q6.

    Chapter 4's climate sensitivity is likely about 2.5 to 4 °C for each doubling. Your answer to Q5 is more than twice that. In four or five sentences, say what else differed between the Ypresian and the last ice age, why deep time gives a bigger number, and which number matters for this century.

    (4 points)