Exercise 5B: When is the next ice age?
Pages: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/ice-ages/, "A Million Years of Ice Ages: Sunlight, Ice and Carbon Dioxide", with https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/milankovitch/ for the orbit
Chapter: 5, "Past Climate Change"
Time: about 30 minutes
The question
The ice ages came and went with Earth's orbit. What part did CO₂ play, and what does our fossil carbon do to the next one?
What to do
- Open A Million Years of Ice Ages. It opens on "The last 800,000 years": the summer Sunlight at 65 °N, the ice on land beside the sea-level record, the CO₂ beside the ice cores, and the temperature. Read the lines under the graphs: how closely the model's ice follows the sea-level record (the correlation), and how big its ice gets.
- Turn off the CO₂ feedback. Under "What the model includes", untick "Carbon dioxide follows the temperature and the ice", and read the same lines again. Then tick it again.
- Look ahead. Open "The next million years". The page opens with 1,000 GtC of fossil carbon. Read the lines under the graphs: when ice starts to grow again with no fossil carbon, and with yours. Then set the fossil carbon to 3,000 GtC and read them again.
- See the orbit. Optional: open Milankovitch Cycles and look at how round Earth's orbit is now and over the next 100,000 years.
What to hand in
- Five numbers: Q1 to Q5.
- One short answer, a few sentences: Q6.
The questions
- Q1.
With the CO₂ following the temperature and the ice, as the page opens, what is the correlation between the model's ice and the sea-level record over the last 800,000 years?
- Q2.
With the CO₂ held still at 278 ppm, what is the correlation now?
- Q3.
On "The next million years", with no fossil carbon, how many years from now does ice start to grow again?
Answer in years.
- Q4.
With 1,000 GtC of fossil carbon, as the page opens, how many years from now does ice start to grow again?
Answer in years.
- Q5.
With 3,000 GtC of fossil carbon?
Answer in years.
- Q6.
In four or five sentences: if the orbit sets the timing of the ice ages, why does turning off the CO₂ feedback make the model's ice ages so much weaker (Q1 and Q2)? And why does fossil carbon put off the next ice age for so long (Q3 to Q5)?
(4 points)