Exercise 7A: Many models, many futures
Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/many-models/, "Many Models, Many Futures"
Chapter: 7, "Climate Scenarios" (part B: Chapter 8, "Future Climate Change")
Time: about 40 minutes
The question
When climate models disagree about the future, how much of the disagreement comes from what people do, how much from the models, and how much from the weather?
What to do
- Read the world's temperature. Open the page. It shows the whole world's temperature in 2081–2100, compared with 1850–1900, for all four scenarios. Read the table, including the rows for the IPCC's assessment.
- Look early and late. Press "2021–2040", then "2081–2100". Watch how the colored lines spread.
- Measure why. Open the "Why they differ" tab. Read the three numbers for 2021–2040 and for 2081–2100, and find where the orange and blue lines cross.
- Watch one model's weather. Back on "Every model", choose "A line for each model, single years" and pick out one model.
- Part B, for Chapter 8. Tick SSP3-7.0 only, keep 2081–2100, and compare "The world's land", "The world's oceans" and "Arctic Ocean".
What to hand in
- Four numbers, each with its units: Q1 to Q3 and Q5.
- Two short answers, a few sentences each: Q4 and Q6.
The questions
- Q1.
For the whole world's temperature in 2081–2100, compared with 1850–1900, under SSP5-8.5: what is the average of the models? Give your answer in °C.
Answer in °C.
- Q2.
Same place, period and scenario: what is the top of the IPCC's assessed very likely range? Give your answer in °C.
Answer in °C.
- Q3.
On the "Why they differ" tab, for the whole world's temperature with all four scenarios ticked: how far apart are the models, on average, in 2021–2040? Give your answer in °C.
Answer in °C.
- Q4.
In 2021–2040 the scenarios are only about 0.04 °C apart, but by 2081–2100 they're 0.95 °C apart, more than the models' 0.64. In three or four sentences, explain why the scenarios matter so little in the next twenty years and so much by the end of the century. Then say what this means for the sentence "the models can't agree, so we don't know how much warming is coming."
(4 points)
- Q5.
Tick SSP3-7.0 only and keep 2081–2100. What is the models' average warming of the Arctic Ocean, compared with 1850–1900? Give your answer in °C.
Answer in °C.
- Q6.
With the same settings, the world's land warms by 5.15 °C and the world's oceans by 3.36 °C, while the Arctic Ocean warms more than three times as much as the world's oceans. In three or four sentences, use Chapter 8 to explain both differences.
(3 points)