Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 7B: Write a storyline, get an emissions path

Pages: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/kaya/, "Four Factors, One Atmosphere", then En-ROADS (en-roads.climateinteractive.org), Climate Interactive and MIT Sloan's free climate policy simulator, listed on the site's Models and Data page, https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/

Chapter: 7, "Climate Scenarios" (with Chapter 11, "Economics of Fire")

Time: about 50 minutes

The question

A scenario starts as a story about people. How does a story become numbers for population, income, energy and emissions? And how much does the answer depend on the model that does the arithmetic?

What to do

You'll turn stories into numbers twice: first with a very simple model on this book's site, then with a much bigger one. Part A works on a phone. Part B needs a computer or tablet: En-ROADS doesn't run on phones.

Part A: Four Factors, One Atmosphere. The carbon the world emits from burning fossil fuels is its population × income per person × the energy used for each dollar of income (energy intensity) × the carbon emitted for each unit of energy (carbon intensity). Chapter 11 calls this the Kaya identity. The page grows the world's population and income from 2025 to 2100 and turns them into emissions, CO₂ in the air and warming. You set three things: how fast energy intensity falls, how fast carbon intensity falls, and "catch-up growth", how much faster poorer economies grow than the richest. You can't set the population: it follows from income, because families get smaller as people get richer.

  1. Open the page (https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/kaya/) and read the summary under the graphs. The sentence that starts "With your choices" gives the emissions, the CO₂ and the warming in 2100 for the settings on the left.
  2. Regional Rivalry. Chapter 7's running example is SSP3, a world where "fragmented cooperation and slow development make it hard both to cut emissions and to adapt" (7.2). Set catch-up growth to 0.5, energy intensity to 0.5 and carbon intensity to 0.3. (This address opens these settings: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/kaya/?k=0.5&a=0.5&b=0.3.) Write down the emissions and the warming in 2100. Then click "Economy" and write down the population in 2100 and the income of the poorest tenth of people.
  3. Fossil-fuelled growth. Now a world that grows fast and keeps burning more coal, oil and gas: catch-up growth 2.5, energy intensity 0.9 (its 2000–2024 pace) and carbon intensity 0, so the energy gets no cleaner at all. (Address: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/kaya/?k=2.5&a=0.9&b=0.) Write down the same four numbers.
  4. Your own world. Write three sentences about a world in 2100 that could happen, the way Chapter 7's "climate movies" do: how well countries cooperate, how fast poorer places develop, and what happens to energy. Then choose the three settings that fit your story. Write down your settings, the same four numbers, and the page's address, which now holds your settings.

Part B: En-ROADS. En-ROADS is a model of the whole world's energy, land and climate, from Climate Interactive and the MIT Sloan School of Management. Its sliders stand for policies and for assumptions about the world.

  1. Open En-ROADS (en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html) and click "Get Started". The big number on the right is the warming in 2100, above the late 1800s. With every slider at "status quo", write it down: that's the baseline.
  2. Regional Rivalry again. Under "Growth", click the word "Population" and type 11.4 in the box (billion people in 2100, the top of the United Nations' range). Close the panel with the × at its top right. Click "Economic Growth" and type 0.5 in the box for "Long-term economic growth (GDP per person)". Close it. Drag both Energy Efficiency sliders, under Transport and under Buildings and Industry, all the way to the left. Write down the warming. (This address opens these settings: en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?p63=11.4&p235=0.5&p47=0&p50=0.)
  3. Start again: choose Simulation, then Reset Policies.
  4. Fossil-fuelled growth again. Set Population to 9 and long-term economic growth to 2.5. Drag the Coal, Oil and Natural Gas sliders all the way to the right, to "encouraged": that's a subsidy that makes each fuel cheaper. Write down the warming. (Address: en-roads.climateinteractive.org/scenario.html?p63=9&p235=2.5&p516=-50&p517=-50&p518=-50.)
  5. Your own world again. Reset, and build your story from step 4 in En-ROADS, with any sliders you like. Write down which sliders you moved, and the warming.
  6. Look around. In both runs, look at the left graph, "Global Sources of Primary Energy", and at the Graphs menu at the top. Note what En-ROADS keeps track of that the Four Factors page doesn't.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    Report the emissions in 2100, the warming in 2100, the population in 2100 and the poorest tenth's income in 2100 for Regional Rivalry (step 2) and for fossil-fuelled growth (step 3). Which world has more people? Which emits more? Chapter 7 says, about SSP3 and SSP5, that "head count alone doesn't warm the planet". Do your numbers agree? Explain using the four factors.

    (4 points)

  2. Q2.

    Hand in your three sentences from step 4, your three settings, and one sentence for each setting saying which part of your story it stands for. Report the emissions, the warming and the population in 2100, and the page's address with your settings.

    (4 points)

  3. Q3.

    Report the En-ROADS warming in 2100 for the baseline (step 5), Regional Rivalry (step 6) and fossil-fuelled growth (step 8), with the version number at the bottom right of the screen. How far apart are the two worlds in En-ROADS, and how far apart were they on the Four Factors page? Give one reason, from what you saw, why the two models spread them so differently.

    (4 points)

  4. Q4.

    Name two things En-ROADS keeps track of that the Four Factors page doesn't, and for each one say how it could change the emissions path of your own world (step 9). Then name one thing Chapter 7 says even a big integrated assessment model leaves out or treats crudely.

    (3 points)

  5. Q5.

    Chapter 7 follows a scenario through a chain of handoffs: a storyline, then quantities for population, income and energy, then emissions and land use, then an Earth system model's climate, then impacts on people. In one paragraph: which links of that chain did the Four Factors page do, and which did En-ROADS do? Which of the numbers you wrote down are what Chapter 7 calls intermediate pathways, and which kind of number would actually be handed to an Earth system model? Why is neither tool's warming an Earth system model's projection?

    (4 points)