Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 8A: Rainfall is not water supply

Pages: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/watershed/, "Rainfall Is Not Water Supply: A Watershed in a Warmer World" (the watershed model), and https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/water-balance/, "Where the Rain Goes: The Water Balance in 16 Climate Models" (the climate models)

Chapter: 8, "Future Climate Change"

Time: about 50 to 60 minutes

The question

If a watershed gets the same rain and snow but the air is warmer, what happens to the water that reaches its river, and when?

What to do

  1. Start with snow. Open the page. It's the Merced River above Yosemite Valley, warmed by 3 °C with the same rain and snow. Compare the gray and red lines in the three graphs, and read the table "The year".
  2. Try a rain-fed river. Choose the French Broad River above Asheville. Read the yearly runoff and evaporative demand, now and warmer. Then set "Change in rain and snow (%)" to 10.
  3. Try Mediterranean hills. Choose the Sierra Morena hills. Set the change in rain and snow to −10, and read "Months with the soil less than half full".
  4. Check the books. For any one setting, add the warmer year's evapotranspiration and runoff, and compare them with its precipitation.
  5. Ask the climate models. Open the climate models' page. It opens on the Mediterranean, the region around the Sierra Morena hills. Read the table "The year". Then set the watershed model to about what those models give the Mediterranean late in this century: 4 °C warmer, with 15% less rain and snow.
  6. A humid region. On the climate models' page, choose Eastern North America, the region around the French Broad. Then set the watershed model to the French Broad, 5 °C warmer with 10% more rain and snow, about what the climate models give that region.
  7. A snowy region. On the climate models' page, choose Western North America, the region around the Merced, and read "The month with the most runoff". Then set the watershed model to the Merced, 4.5 °C warmer with 5% more rain and snow, and read the same row.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    On the Merced, 3 °C warmer with the same rain and snow, how much runoff reaches the river in a year? Give your answer in millimeters.

    Answer in mm.

  2. Q2.

    Same settings: how deep is the deepest snowpack of the warmer year? Give your answer in millimeters of water.

    Answer in mm.

  3. Q3.

    On the French Broad, 3 °C warmer with the same rain and snow, how much runoff reaches the river in a year? Give your answer in millimeters.

    Answer in mm.

  4. Q4.

    Keep the French Broad 3 °C warmer, and add 10% to the rain and snow. How much runoff reaches the river now? Give your answer in millimeters.

    Answer in mm.

  5. Q5.

    In the Sierra Morena hills, 3 °C warmer with 10% less rain and snow, in how many months of the year is the soil less than half full?

    Answer in months.

  6. Q6.

    Chapter 8 writes the water balance as P − E = R + ΔS. Over the page's settled year ΔS is zero. In three or four sentences, use that equation and your numbers from Q3 to explain why the French Broad's runoff falls even though its precipitation doesn't change. Then say why its "Evaporative demand" and "Evapotranspiration" rows are nearly equal, but the Sierra Morena's aren't.

    (4 points)

  7. Q7.

    On the Merced, warming moves the river's biggest month from May to April, and the soil runs low by late summer. A farmer downstream needs irrigation water in July and August. In three or four sentences, explain what the warmer year does to that farmer, using the snowpack graph, and name one thing people could do about it that Chapter 8 mentions.

    (3 points)

  8. Q8.

    On the climate models' page, as it opens (the Mediterranean), by what percentage does the average of the models change the yearly runoff from 1995–2014 to 2081–2100?

    Answer in %.

  9. Q9.

    Same page and region: how many of the 16 models have less runoff in 2081–2100 than in 1995–2014?

    Answer in models.

  10. Q10.

    In the watershed model, choose the Sierra Morena hills and set the warming to 4 °C and the change in rain and snow to −15%. How much runoff reaches the streams in a year? Give your answer in millimeters.

    Answer in mm.

  11. Q11.

    On the climate models' page, choose Eastern North America. By what percentage does the average of the models change the yearly runoff?

    Answer in %.

  12. Q12.

    In the watershed model, choose the French Broad River and set the warming to 5 °C and the change in rain and snow to +10%. How much runoff reaches the river in a year? Give your answer in millimeters.

    Answer in mm.

  13. Q13.

    In Q11 and Q12, both pages have about 10% more rain and snow, but the watershed model's river shrinks and the climate models' runoff grows. In four or five sentences, use P − E = R to explain where the difference comes from, and say which page you would trust for how much wetter or drier a region gets, and why. The About tab of the climate models' page will help.

    (4 points)

  14. Q14.

    On the climate models' page, the month with the most runoff in Western North America moves from March to February. In the watershed model, with the Merced 4.5 °C warmer and 5% more rain and snow, it moves from May to March. In three or four sentences, explain why both move earlier, and why the Merced's biggest month comes later in the year than the region's.

    (3 points)