Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 9C: The way back down

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/data/co2-up-and-down/, "The Way Back Down: CO₂ Up and Down in Eight Climate Models"

Chapter: 9, "The One-Way Thermostat"

Time: about 30 minutes

The question

If we take the carbon dioxide back out of the air, does the climate go back the way it came?

What to do

  1. Open the page and read "The experiment" on the About tab. In each model, CO₂ rose 1% a year for 140 years, to four times where it started, then fell 1% a year back to the start, and was held there.
  2. Open "Same CO₂, up and down". It opens on the average of the models, at about 568 ppm, double the start. Read the lines under the graph: they compare the 21 years around that CO₂ on the way up with the 21 years on the way down that had the same CO₂.
  3. Try three models. With "Model", choose UKESM1-0-LL, then GFDL-ESM4, then NorESM2-LM, and read the same lines for each.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    For the average of the models, at double the starting CO₂, how much warmer was the way down than the way up?

    Answer in °C.

  2. Q2.

    The same, for UKESM1-0-LL.

    Answer in °C.

  3. Q3.

    The same, for GFDL-ESM4.

    Answer in °C.

  4. Q4.

    The same, for NorESM2-LM.

    Answer in °C.

  5. Q5.

    Go back to the average of the models. Once CO₂ was all the way back where it started, how much warmer than the control run were the first 21 years?

    Answer in °C.

  6. Q6.

    At the same CO₂, the way down is warmer than the way up, and when CO₂ is back where it started, the world is still warmer than it was. In four or five sentences, explain why, using Chapter 9. Then say why the models disagree so much about how much warmer (Q2 to Q4), and what that means for a plan that counts on removing CO₂ later.

    (4 points)