Climate Change: Simple, Serious, Solvable › Models and Data

Where the Carbon Goes: Air, Ocean, Land and Warming to the Year 3000

Every year we burn fossil fuel, and the carbon goes into the air. The ocean and the land take some of it back out. The rest warms the world. Set how the ocean, the land and the climate respond, see whether the model matches the past, then follow the carbon a thousand years ahead.

Open in a new window

Loading the data…

The past: carbon dioxide and warming since 1850, beside the measurements

The climate

The IPCC's best estimate is 3, and its likely range is 2.5 to 4. The page opens at 2.5, which fits the whole record best in this model.

The ocean

How fast the warm surface water trades places with the cooler water under it, before any warming. More mixing carries more carbon and more heat down.

The land

With nitrogen to spare. Experiments in young forests found close to 50%, and in old forests almost nothing.

Mature forests don't grow forever: trees die as fast as new wood grows. This is how much more wood a forest can hold before that happens.

Below 1, plants run short of nitrogen when they grow faster, and nitrogen from burning helps them. At 1, nitrogen never limits growth.

Plants grow best at 25 °C. Narrower: warming helps the cold north more and hurts the tropics sooner.

The record

Some scientists think countries have reported about 6% more than they burned. If so, less carbon went into the land than the budget says.

  • This model
  • Measured

Move over the graph, or select it and use the arrow keys, to read values.

Where the carbon from fossil fuel went, 1850 to 2024
Billions of tonnes of carbonThis modelCarbon budget
Burned
Stayed in the air
Went into the ocean
Went into the land, after clearing

Only the burning is given. The model is told how much fossil fuel was burned each year, and nothing about the carbon dioxide in the air. It works that out: what the ocean and the land don't take up stays in the air. Then it works out the warming. So the thin gray lines are a test.

Make it match. The model as it opens runs high in carbon dioxide from the 1950s on. Try the land's settings: more CO₂ fertilization, more room for wood, less clearing. Several different settings match the past about equally well. Which is right matters for the future, as the next views show.

The budget doesn't add up either. The Global Carbon Budget's own counts of clearing and of the land's growth miss what the air and the ocean say by about 1.6 billion tonnes a year in the 1950s. This model, which follows the same records of clearing, runs high in the same years.