Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 13B: Half comes back, eventually

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/earthcarbon/, "Where the Carbon Goes: Air, Ocean, Land and Warming to the Year 3000"

Chapter: 13, "Cleaning Up the Mess" (with Chapter 9, "The One-Way Thermostat")

Time: about 30 minutes

The question

If we take carbon back out of the air, how much of it comes back out of the ocean and the land? And what do we even mean by "comes back"?

What to do

  1. Open the page and choose a scenario that removes carbon. Open "3. Where the carbon goes". Set "Scenario after 2024" to SSP5-3.4-overshoot, which burns a lot, then cuts fast and takes carbon back out of the air for about a century. Set "Show the years up to" to 3000.
  2. Read the two air lines. The solid orange line is the carbon in the air in this scenario. The thin dashed orange line is the same scenario without the removal: the same burning, but nothing taken back out. The gap between them is the carbon that the removal keeps out of the air.
  3. Read the lines under the graph. They say how much carbon the scenario takes back out, and how much of it stays out at the end of the removal and in 3000.
  4. Move along the years. Move over the graph, or select it and use the arrow keys, to 2100. The line of text under the graph now says how much has been taken out so far, and how much of it stays out.
  5. Try another. Choose SSP1-1.9 and read the lines under the graph again.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    In SSP5-3.4-overshoot, how much carbon is taken back out of the air in all? Give your answer in billions of tonnes (GtC).

    Answer in GtC.

  2. Q2.

    In 2100, while the removal is still going on, what percentage of the carbon taken out so far stays out of the air, beside the same scenario without the removal?

    Answer in percent.

  3. Q3.

    In 2169, when the removal ends, what percentage of it stays out of the air?

    Answer in percent.

  4. Q4.

    And in 3000?

    Answer in percent.

  5. Q5.

    In SSP1-1.9, what percentage of the carbon taken out stays out of the air in 3000?

    Answer in percent.

  6. Q6.

    Chapters 9 and 13 say that about half of the CO₂ removed comes back out of the land and ocean. Your answers to Q2 to Q4 are 79%, 55% and 24% staying out. In four or five sentences: what do we mean by "comes back"? Why does the answer depend on when you look, and on what you compare with? Is "about half" wrong?

    (4 points)

  7. Q7.

    Many climate models' runs stop in 2100, before these slow processes have caught up. In three or four sentences: what does stopping at 2100 do to what a model says about removal? What does it mean for the price of lowering the CO₂ in the air by 1 ppm, which The Mop and the Bill doubles for the half that comes back?

    (3 points)