Models and Data › Exercises

Exercise 14C: The hidden cost

Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/hidden-cost/, "The Hidden Cost: A Fuel, Its Smoke and a Price on Pollution"

Chapter: 14, "Planetary Prosperity"

Time: about 30 minutes

The question

When burning a fuel harms people outside the market, what does a price on the pollution change, and in what sense is the result "optimal"?

What to do

  1. Open the page and look at the graph. It's the supply-and-demand graph of section 14.2, for a made-up fuel. The market alone settles where the blue demand line crosses the dark supply line. Each ton burned also does $30 of harm to people outside the market, and nobody in the market pays it. The red dashed line is the social cost: the seller's cost plus that harm.
  2. Move the harm. Slide "Cost that falls on other people ($ a ton)" from 0 to 80 and back to 30. Watch the amount burned and the price the buyer pays.
  3. Put a price on the pollution. Slide "Price on the pollution ($ a ton)" up from 0. Watch the shaded triangle, and the row of the table that begins "The pie is smaller than it could be by". Find the price that makes the pie as big as it can be.
  4. Get the harm wrong. Leave the price where you found it, and set the harm to $60 a ton, as if the harm had been underestimated by half.

What to hand in

The questions

  1. Q1.

    With the page as it opens ($30 of harm for each ton, no price on the pollution), how much harm does the smoke do to other people each year? Give your answer in billions of dollars.

    Answer in billion dollars a year.

  2. Q2.

    With the harm at $30 a ton, what price on the pollution makes the pie as big as it can be? Give your answer in dollars a ton.

    Answer in dollars a ton.

  3. Q3.

    At that price, how much less fuel is burned each year than in the market alone? Give your answer in millions of tons.

    Answer in million tons a year.

  4. Q4.

    At that price, by how many dollars a ton does the price the buyer pays go up? (The rest of the $30 comes out of what the seller keeps.)

    Answer in dollars a ton.

  5. Q5.

    At that price, how much harm is avoided each year, compared with the market alone? Give your answer in billions of dollars.

    Answer in billion dollars a year.

  6. Q6.

    Keep the price at $30 a ton, and set the harm to $60 a ton. By how much is the pie now smaller than it could be? Give your answer in billions of dollars a year.

    Answer in billion dollars a year.

  7. Q7.

    At the biggest pie, the table still shows harm to other people. In four or five sentences: what does "optimal" mean on this graph, and what does it leave out? Use your answer to Q6 and Chapter 14 to name at least two things it leaves out.

    (4 points)