Climate Change: Simple, Serious, Solvable › Models and Data

The Hidden Cost: A Fuel, Its Smoke and a Price on Pollution

Buyers and sellers of a fuel settle on a price and an amount. The smoke costs other people something too, but nobody in the market pays for it. Put a price on the pollution and see what changes: how much is burned, what the buyer pays and how much harm is avoided.

Open in a new window

What each ton's smoke costs people outside the market: sickness, early deaths, soot to clean and, for its CO₂, warming. Nobody in the market pays it.

A tax on each ton burned, which the seller passes on to the buyer as best it can. Economists call it a Pigouvian tax, after Arthur Pigou.

  • Demand
  • Supply: the seller's cost
  • Social cost: the seller's cost plus the harm
  • The seller's cost plus the price
  • How much smaller the pie is
What the market does
Fuel burned
The price the buyer pays
What the seller keeps
The fuel bill, paid to the sellers
The price on the pollution brings in
The harm to other people
Harm avoided, beside the market alone
The pie is smaller than it could be by
The biggest pie burns

The best amount isn't zero. Where the pie is biggest, some fuel is still burned and some harm is still done. Each of those tons is worth more to its buyer than it costs the seller and the people downwind together.

The biggest pie, not fair slices. The graph says nothing about who gets which slice. The people downwind still bear the harm that's left, unless the money from the price reaches them.

This is a made-up market. Its two straight lines are chosen to be easy to follow, not to match any real fuel. The About tab has every equation.