Exercise 9A: Match the past, follow the carbon
Page: https://simpleserioussolvable.org/models/earthcarbon/, "Where the Carbon Goes: Air, Ocean, Land and Warming to the Year 3000"
Chapter: 9, "The One-Way Thermostat"
Time: about 40 minutes
The question
Where has the carbon we've burned gone, and how much of it will still be in the air a thousand years from now?
What to do
- Open the page. It opens on "1. The past": the model's carbon dioxide and warming from 1750 to 2024, beside the measurements. Under the graph, the table "Where the carbon from fossil fuel went, 1850 to 2024" has two columns: "This model" and "Carbon budget", the Global Carbon Budget's own count.
- Read the line under the table. It says how far the model's carbon dioxide is from the measurements in a typical year since 1960.
- Make it match. Open the land's settings and change them until the model's carbon dioxide follows the measured line closely. Write down your settings and the typical miss.
- Follow the carbon. Press "Back to the opening settings". Open "3. Where the carbon goes", set "Show the years up to" to 3000, and read the line under the graph. Then set "Scenario after 2024" to SSP5-8.5 and read it again.
What to hand in
- Six numbers, each with its units: Q1 to Q4, Q6 and Q7.
- Two short answers, a few sentences each: Q5 and Q8.
The questions
- Q1.
By the Global Carbon Budget's count, how much of the carbon from fossil fuel burned from 1850 to 2024 stayed in the air? Give your answer in billions of tonnes of carbon (GtC).
Answer in GtC.
- Q2.
By the same count, how much went into the ocean?
Answer in GtC.
- Q3.
And how much went into the land, after the carbon released by clearing forests is taken away?
Answer in GtC.
- Q4.
With the page as it opens, by how many ppm is the model's carbon dioxide off from the measurements, in a typical year since 1960?
Answer in ppm.
- Q5.
Make the model match the past. Report the land settings you changed and the typical miss you ended with. Then say in two or three sentences which way you moved the land's settings, and why that brings the model's carbon dioxide down.
(3 points)
- Q6.
Press "Back to the opening settings". Follow SSP2-4.5, the middle of the road, to the year 3000. What percentage of the carbon burned since 1750 is still in the air in 3000?
Answer in percent.
- Q7.
Now choose SSP5-8.5, very high emissions. What percentage of the carbon burned since 1750 is still in the air in 3000?
Answer in percent.
- Q8.
The more carbon is burned, the bigger the share still in the air a thousand years later (Q6 and Q7). In three or four sentences, explain why, using Chapter 9. Then say what the warming does after the burning stops, and why.
(4 points)